Listed below are the names of all of the players who have ever appeared on the Paternoster Gang roster since the league's inception. This list is accurate as of the end of the 2017 season.

QUARTERBACKS
Derek Anderson, Browns (2007-2008)
Blake Bortles, Jaguars (2017)
Sam Bradford, Rams (2013)
Tom Brady, Patriots (2002, 2014-2015)
Drew Brees, Saints (2016-2017)
Jacoby Brissett, Colts (2017)
Marc Bulger, Rams (2004-2005)
Matt Cassel, Patriots/Chiefs (2008-2009)
Jay Cutler, Broncos/Bears (2008-2011, 2013)
Austin Davis, Rams (2014)
Brett Favre, Vikings (2010)
A.J. Feeley, Dolphins/Chargers (2005)
Rich Gannon, Raiders (2003)
Rex Grossman, Redskins (2011)
Kelly Holcomb, Browns (2003)
Brian Hoyer, Texans (2015)
Tarvaris Jackson, Seahawks (2011)
Colin Kaepernick, 49ers (2016)
J.P. Losman, Bills (2007)
Jamie Martin, Rams (2005)
Shane Matthews, Redskins (2002)
Josh McCown, Cardinals (2004)
Steve McNair, Titans (2002)
Carson Palmer, Bengals (2006-2007)
Christian Ponder, Vikings (2012)
Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers (2006, 2012)
Tony Romo, Cowboys (2011-2013)
Matt Ryan, Falcons (2016-2017)
Alex Smith, Chiefs (2015)
Geno Smith, Jets (2013-2014)

RUNNING BACKS
Javorius Allen, Ravens (2015)
Montee Ball, Broncos (2015)
Joique Bell, Lions (2012)
Giovani Bernard, Bengals (2013-2015)
Devontae Booker, Broncos (2017)
Chris Brown, Titans (2007)
Donald Brown, Colts (2010)
Ronnie Brown, Dolphins (2005, 2010)
Reggie Bush, 49ers (2015)
Jesse Chatman, Dolphins (2007)
Tevin Coleman, Falcons (2015)
Reuben Droughns, Broncos (2006)
Warrick Dunn, Buccaneers (2002)
Jonathan Dwyer, Steelers (2012)
Justin Fargas, Raiders (2004)
Toby Gerhart, Vikings/Jaguars (2012, 2014)
Lamar Gordon, Dolphins (2004)
Ahman Green, Texans (2007)
William Green, Browns (2004)
BenJarvus Green-Ellis, Patriots (2008, 2011)
Shonn Greene, Jets (2012)
Quentin Griffin, Broncos (2004)
Jerome Harrison, Browns (2009)
Verron Haynes, Steelers (2005)
Tim Hightower, Cardinals (2009)
Ronnie Hillman, Broncos (2014)
Carlos Hyde, 49ers (2014-2016)
Mark Ingram, Saints (2016)
Chris Ivory, Jaguars (2017)
Brandon Jackson, Browns (2011)
Edgerrin James, Cardinals (2007)
Chris Johnson, Cardinals (2017)
Rudi Johnson, Bengals/Lions (2005, 2008)
Felix Jones, Cowboys (2009)
Kevin Jones, Lions (2006)
Thomas Jones, Cardinals (2002)
Eddie Lacy, Seahawks (2017)
Dorsey Levens, Eagles (2004)
Marshawn Lynch, Raiders (2017)
LeSean McCoy, Eagles/Bills (2011-2017)
Willis McGahee, Ravens (2007-2008)
Rashard Mendenhall, Steelers (2008)
Travis Minor, Dolphins (2004)
Mewelde Moore, Steelers (2008)
Michael Pittman, Buccaneers (2003)
Isaac Redman, Steelers (2011)
Ray Rice, Ravens (2014)
Stevan Ridley, Patriots (2013)
Charles Sims, Buccaneers (2015)
Wendell Smallwood, Eagles (2017)
Antone Smith, Falcons (2013)
Onterrio Smith, Vikings (2004)
Duce Staley, Steelers (2006)
James Starks, Packers (2015)
LaRod Stephens-Howling, Cardinals/Steelers (2010, 2013)
Jonathan Stewart, Panthers (2008)
Ben Tate, Texans (2011)
Anthony Thomas, Bears (2003-2004)
Pierre Thomas, Saints (2011)
Chris Thompson, Redskins (2016-2017)
Mike Tolbert, Panthers (2013)
Robert Turbin, Seahawks (2014)
Derrick Ward, Giants/Buccaneers (2007, 2010)
Leon Washington, Seahawks (2011)
Damien Williams, Dolphins (2017)
DeAngelo Williams, Panthers (2009, 2012)
Jonathan Williams, Broncos (2017)
Moe Williams, Vikings (2003)
Ricky Williams, Dolphins (2002-2003)
DeShawn Wynn, Packers (2007)
T.J. Yeldon, Jaguars (2016)

WIDE RECEIVERS
Kamar Aiken, Ravens (2015)
Danario Alexander, Rams (2011)
Keenan Allen, Chargers (2013)
Danny Amendola, Rams/Patriots (2009, 2014)
Miles Austin, Browns (2014)
Marty Booker, Dolphins (2005-2006)
Dwayne Bowe, Chiefs (2009)
Deion Branch, Patriots (2004-2005)
Dezmon Briscoe, Buccaneers (2011)
Kenny Britt, Rams/Browns (2014, 2017)
Reggie Brown, Eagles (2008)
Troy Brown, Patriots (2003)
Vincent Brown, Chargers (2011)
Plaxico Burress, Steelers (2012)
Chris Chambers, Dolphins (2004)
Mark Clayton, Ravens (2009)
Randall Cobb, Packers (2015)
Laveranues Coles, Jets (2005)
Austin Collie, Colts (2011)
Kevin Curtis, Rams/Eagles (2005, 2007)
Andre' Davis, Texans (2007)
Eric Decker, Jets (2014)
Stefon Diggs, Vikings (2015)
Aaron Dobson, Patriots (2014)
Julian Edelman, Patriots (2012)
Braylon Edwards, Browns (2007-2008)
Brian Finneran, Falcons (2003)
Malcom Floyd, Chargers (2012)
Michael Floyd, Cardinals (2015)
Devin Funchess, Panthers (2017)
Joey Galloway, Buccaneers (2006)
Pierre Garcon, Colts/49ers (2011, 2017)
Ted Ginn Jr., Saints (2017)
Anthony Gonzalez, Colts (2010)
Az-Zahir Hakim, Lions (2002)
Marvin Harrison, Colts (2002)
Donald Hayes, Patriots (2002)
Devin Hester, Bears/Falcons (2011, 2014)
Santonio Holmes, Steelers (2008-2009)
Torry Holt, Rams/Jaguars (2003-2006, 2009)
Darrell Jackson, 49ers (2007)
Vincent Jackson, Chargers (2007)
Kevin Johnson, Browns/Ravens (2002-2003)
Keyshawn Johnson, Panthers (2006)
Stevie Johnson, Bills (2013)
Jacoby Jones, Texans (2010)
Marvin Jones, Bengals (2015)
Brandon LaFell, Panthers/Patriots (2012, 2015)
Marqise Lee, Jaguars (2016)
Greg Little, Browns (2012)
Dane Looker, Rams (2004)
Jeremy Maclin, Chiefs (2015-2016)
Mario Manningham, 49ers (2012)
Brandon Marshall, Broncos/Dolphins/Bears (2009-2014)
Derrick Mason, Ravens (2010)
Jordan Matthews, Eagles (2016)
Dexter McCluster, Chiefs (2013)
Robert Meachem, Saints (2008, 2010-2011)
Rob Moore, Broncos (2002)
Johnnie Morton, Chiefs (2004)
Eric Moulds, Texans (2006)
DeVante Parker, Dolphins (2015-2016)
Preston Parker, Buccaneers (2011)
Cordarrelle Patterson, Vikings (2016)
Brian Quick, Rams (2013-2014)
Rueben Randle, Giants (2015)
Antwaan Randle El, Steelers/Redskins (2004, 2007)
Andre Roberts, Cardinals (2012)
Allen Robinson, Jaguars (2014)
Koren Robinson, Seahawks (2002)
Eddie Royal, Broncos/Chargers (2011, 2013)
Tajae Sharpe, Titans (2016)
Sterling Shepard, Giants (2016)
Cecil Shorts, Jaguars/Texans (2014-2015)
Steve Smith, Panthers (2012-2013)
Donte' Stallworth, Saints/Browns (2002, 2008)
Kenny Stills, Saints/Dolphins (2013-2014, 2017)
Brandon Stokley, Colts (2005)
Demaryius Thomas, Broncos (2017)
Kevin Walter, Texans (2008, 2010)
Robert Woods, Bills (2016)

TIGHT ENDS
Kyle Brady, Jaguars (2003)
Trey Burton, Eagles (2017)
Brent Celek, Eagles (2016)
Scott Chandler, Bills (2014)
Desmond Clark, Bears (2007)
Charles Clay, Dolphins (2013)
Chris Cooley, Redskins (2005)
Jeff Cumberland, Jets (2013)
Fred Davis, Redskins (2011)
Ed Dickson, Panthers (2017)
Zach Ertz, Eagles (2016-2017)
Anthony Fasano, Dolphins/Titans (2012, 2015)
Bubba Franks, Packers (2006)
Daniel Graham, Patriots (2002, 2005)
Rob Gronkowski, Patriots (2010)
Clay Harbor, Jaguars (2014)
Todd Heap, Ravens (2006)
Hunter Henry, Chargers (2016)
Travis Kelce, Chiefs (2015)
Dustin Keller, Jets (2012)
Erron Kinney, Titans (2004)
Tyler Kroft, Bengals (2017)
Marcedes Lewis, Jaguars (2008, 2012)
Tim Massaquoi, Bills (2009)
Heath Miller, Steelers (2008, 2011)
Zach Miller, Raiders (2009)
Brandon Myers, Raiders (2012)
Leonard Pope, Cardinals (2008)
Dante Rosario, Chargers (2012)
Kyle Rudolph, Vikings (2014)
Bo Scaife, Titans (2009)
Tony Scheffler, Lions (2012)
Matt Schobel, Bengals (2004)
Shannon Sharpe, Broncos (2002)
Jerramy Stevens, Seahawks/Buccaneers (2003, 2009)
Zach Sudfeld, Patriots (2013)
Delanie Walker, Titans (2013)
Wesley Walls, Packers (2003)
Benjamin Watson, Patriots (2009)
Boo Williams, Saints (2004)
Kellen Winslow Jr., Browns/Buccaneers (2007, 2011)
Jason Witten, Cowboys (2010)

PLACEKICKERS
David Akers, Eagles (2007)
Morten Andersen, Vikings (2004)
Connor Barth, Buccaneers (2015)
Rob Bironas, Titans (2009)
Matt Bryant, Falcons (2013)
John Carney, Saints (2008)
Dan Carpenter, Dolphins/Bills (2011, 2015)
Mason Crosby, Packers (2008, 2010, 2013)
Billy Cundiff, Ravens (2011)
Phil Dawson, Browns (2007)
Jason Elam, Broncos (2006)
Nick Folk, Cowboys/Jets (2007, 2011)
Robbie Gould, Bears (2015)
Shayne Graham, Bengals/Texans (2004, 2012)
Jason Hanson, Lions (2009)
Sebastian Janikowski, Raiders (2012)
Nate Kaeding, Chargers (2011)
Josh Lambo, Steelers/Chargers (2015-2016)
Olindo Mare, Dolphins (2003)
Nick Novak, Chargers (2014)
Matt Prater, Lions (2017)
Jeff Reed, Steelers (2009)
Cairo Santos, Chiefs (2015)
Josh Scobee, Jaguars (2008)
Caleb Sturgis, Dolphins (2014)
Mike Vanderjagt, Colts (2005)
Adam Vinatieri, Colts (2016)
Blair Walsh, Vikings/Seahawks (2012, 2017)
Jeff Wilkins, Rams (2002)

DEFENSIVE PLAYERS
John Abraham, Falcons (2006)
Kwon Alexander, Buccaneers (2017)
Champ Bailey, Broncos (2006)
Antoine Behtea, Cardinals (2017)
Derrick Brooks, Buccaneers (2004)
Nate Clements, Bills (2005)
Aaron Donald, Rams (2017)
Tommie Harris, Bears (2007)
Eric Kendricks, Vikings (2016)
Christian Kirksey, Browns (2017)
Leonard Little, Rams (2004-2005)
C.J. Mosley, Ravens (2016)
Troy Polamalu, Steelers (2007)
Nickell Robey, Bills (2016)
Barrett Ruud, Buccaneers (2007)
Zach Thomas, Dolphins (2004, 2006)
Pino Tinoisamoa, Rams (2004)
Roy Williams, Cowboys (2005)
Patrick Willis, 49ers (2007)
Adrian Wilson, Cardinals (2006-2007)
Antoine Winfield, Vikings (2007)
Shareece Wright, Ravens (2016)

DEFENSIVE TEAMS
Atlanta Falcons (2012, 2017)
Baltimore Ravens (2009-2011)
Buffalo Bills (2004, 2009)
Carolina Panthers (2009)
Chicago Bears (2007, 2009)
Cleveland Browns (2009)
Dallas Cowboys (2002, 2009)
Houston Texans (2008)
Miami Dolphins (2005)
Minnesota Vikings (2015)
New England Patriots (2007, 2014-2015)
New Orleans Saints (2008)
Oakland Raiders (2013)
Pittsburgh Steelers (2006, 2008, 2014, 2016)
St. Louis Rams (2003-2004)
San Francisco 49ers (2008, 2013)
Seattle Seahawks (2008, 2012, 2017)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2011)
Tennessee Titans (2002)
Washington Redskins (2016)